Why it matters
- this is the city of the Iliad, so the big question is whether its ruins are really Homer's Troy
- behind that lies an even bigger one: did the Trojan War actually happen?
A mound at Hisarlik — and its many layers
A mound at Hisarlik in northwest Turkey, guarding the Dardanelles.
Troy is a tell: layer built on layer over thousands of years.
| Layer | Roughly when | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Troy I | c.3000 BC | the oldest settlement on the mound |
| Troy VI | down to c.1250 BC | large and rich, with strong walls and towers |
| Troy VIIa | c.1250–1180 BC | rebuilt, short-lived, with signs of war |
| up to Troy IX | Roman times | people lived on the mound for around 3,000 years |
A reminder of what happens when the remains are read through the poems.
The picture any candidate layer has to match.
Two candidate layers, weighed
So which layer, if either, fits? Troy VI's evidence mostly points one way, with a single objection; Troy VIIa's evidence is genuinely read two ways.
| Evidence | Homer's Troy? |
|---|---|
| Walls over 7m high, with towers | For — matches the high, towered walls in the Iliad |
| A large, rich city of perhaps 10,000 people | For — the thriving city Homer describes |
| Destroyed around 1250 BC | For — close to the traditional war date of about 1200 |
| Looks to have been destroyed by an earthquake | Against — a natural disaster rather than the fire and sack of the legend |
| Evidence | Read as a siege (for) | Read another way (against) |
|---|---|---|
| Destroyed by fire | the burning of the city in the legend | a fire could be accidental rather than a sack |
| Houses crammed inside the walls | people sheltering during a siege | simply a poor, overcrowded city |
| Storage jars sunk into the floors | food stockpiled to survive a siege | just a way to save space |